当前位置:主页 > 诊疗指南 > 文章内容

2023 亚太共识:低骨量或骨质疏松但无脆性骨折的绝经后女性骨质

作者:中华医学网发布时间:2026-01-12 08:43浏览:

2023 Asia-Pacific Consensus on Osteoporotic Fracture Prevention in Postmenopausal Women With Low Bone Mass or Osteoporosis but No Fragility Fractures

 
Core Title: Asia-Pacific Consensus on Osteoporotic Fracture Prevention in Postmenopausal Women With Low Bone Mass or Osteoporosis but No Fragility Fractures
 
Released by: Asian Federation of Osteoporosis Societies (AFOS) & Asia Pacific Osteoporosis Foundation (APOF); Hosted by Taiwanese Osteoporosis Association
 
Publication Date: 2023-02-10 (Journal: Journal of Clinical Medicine)
 
Core Objective: Provide region-specific, evidence-based guidance for fracture prevention in postmenopausal women with low bone mass/osteoporosis (no fragility fractures), emphasizing risk stratification, lifestyle optimization, calcium/vitamin D supplementation, pharmacotherapy, and long-term monitoring.
 

 

I. Ten Core Consensus Statements (Expert Consensus)

 
  1. Fracture Risk Assessment: Use FRAX (with country-specific databases) + BMD (T-score) to stratify risk; consider age, prior fracture, parental hip fracture, low BMI, smoking, alcohol use, glucocorticoid use, and rheumatoid arthritis.
  2. Pharmacotherapy Eligibility: Recommend pharmacotherapy for high-risk women (FRAX 10-year major osteoporotic fracture risk ≥20% or hip fracture risk ≥3%; T-score ≤-2.5); conditional for moderate-risk (FRAX major 10–20% or hip 1–3%; T-score -1.0 to -2.5).
  3. First-Line Pharmacotherapy: Alendronate, risedronate, and raloxifene are well-recognized options; zoledronic acid is effective for fracture prevention.
  4. Denosumab & Teriparatide: Denosumab is a first-line alternative; teriparatide is reserved for severe osteoporosis (T-score ≤-3.0) or high fracture risk with failed bisphosphonates.
  5. Calcium & Vitamin D Supplementation: Target 1000–1200mg calcium/day (diet + supplements) and 800–1000 IU vitamin D/day; monitor 25(OH)D levels (target ≥30ng/mL).
  6. Lifestyle Interventions: Mandatory for all women—weight-bearing exercise (3×/week), resistance training (2×/week), smoking cessation, alcohol <10g/day, fall prevention.
  7. Hormone Therapy (HT): Consider HT in early postmenopausal women (≤60 years or <10 years since menopause) with low fracture risk and no contraindications; avoid in high CV/GI risk patients.
  8. Monitoring Strategy: BMD every 2 years; switch therapy if BMD declines >4% at spine/hip or new morphometric vertebral fracture occurs.
  9. Adherence Enhancement: Use simplified regimens (e.g., weekly bisphosphonates, 6-month denosumab injections); educate on fracture risk reduction benefits.
  10. Health Policy Advocacy: Reimburse pharmacotherapy for high-risk women to improve access and reduce fracture burden.
 

 

II. Risk Stratification & Intervention Framework

 

(1) Risk Stratification (FRAX + BMD)

 
Risk Category FRAX 10-Year Risk T-Score Intervention
High Major ≥20% or Hip ≥3% ≤-2.5 Pharmacotherapy + lifestyle + Ca/D
Moderate Major 10–20% or Hip 1–3% -1.0 to -2.5 Conditional pharmacotherapy + lifestyle + Ca/D
Low Major <10% or Hip <1% >-1.0 Lifestyle + Ca/D; monitor BMD annually
 

(2) Stepwise Intervention Protocol

 
  1. Base: Lifestyle optimization (exercise, smoking/alcohol cessation, fall prevention)+Ca/D supplementation (1200mg Ca, 800 IU D/day).
  2. High Risk: Add bisphosphonate (alendronate 70mg/week or risedronate 35mg/week) or denosumab 60mg every 6 months.
  3. Severe/Refractory: Switch to teriparatide 20mcg/day (max 2 years) or romosozumab (120mg/month ×12 months) followed by anti-resorptive therapy.
  4. Monitoring: BMD at 2 years; 25(OH)D and calcium at baseline, 6 months, and annually.
 

 

III. Pharmacotherapy: Efficacy & Safety Summary

 
Agent Fracture Risk Reduction Key Safety Concerns
Alendronate R spine: 47%, R hip: 51% Esophagitis; avoid in eGFR <35mL/min
Risedronate R spine: 41%, R hip: 39% Dyspepsia; lower GI risk vs. alendronate
Zoledronic Acid R spine: 70%, R hip: 41% Acute phase reaction; monitor creatinine
Denosumab R spine: 68%, R hip: 40% Hypocalcemia; infections; rebound fractures after discontinuation
Teriparatide R spine: 65%, R hip: 53% Hypercalcemia; osteosarcoma risk (rodents); max 2 years
Raloxifene R spine: 30%; no hip benefit Hot flashes; venous thromboembolism risk
 

 

IV. Lifestyle & Nutritional Interventions (Expert Consensus)

 
  1. Exercise:
    • Weight-bearing: Brisk walking, stair climbing, dancing (3×30min/week).
    • Resistance: Weight training, elastic bands (2×30min/week); focus on core and lower limbs.
    • Balance: Tai Chi, single-leg stands (daily) to reduce fall risk.
     
  2. Nutrition:
    • Calcium: Dairy, tofu, leafy greens (avoid oxalate-rich veggies raw); supplements if diet <1000mg/day.
    • Vitamin D: Sunlight (15–30min/day, face/arms), fatty fish, fortified foods; supplements if 25(OH)D <30ng/mL.
     
  3. Fall Prevention:
    • Home modifications: Remove rugs, install handrails, improve lighting.
    • Gait/balance training; avoid sedatives/hypnotics; review medications for dizziness.
     
 

 

V. Special Populations (Key Adjustments)

 
Population Recommendations
Early Postmenopause (<60 years) HT may be preferred if no CV/GI contraindications; bisphosphonates as alternative
Chronic Kidney Disease (eGFR 30–60) Avoid bisphosphonates; use denosumab with calcium/vitamin D; monitor Ca/P
Glucocorticoid Users Bisphosphonates/denosumab first-line; increase vitamin D to 1000 IU/day
Asian Women Lower BMI cutoff (≥19kg/m²); adjust FRAX for regional databases
 

 

VI. Clinical Takeaways

 
  1. Use FRAX + BMD to stratify fracture risk; offer pharmacotherapy to high-risk women (FRAX major ≥20% or hip ≥3%; T-score ≤-2.5).
  2. Bisphosphonates (alendronate/risedronate) are first-line; denosumab is an alternative; teriparatide for severe cases.
  3. Combine pharmacotherapy with lifestyle optimization, calcium/vitamin D supplementation, and fall prevention.
  4. Monitor BMD every 2 years; switch therapy if BMD declines >4% or new fractures occur.
  5. Advocate for policy support to improve access to pharmacotherapy for high-risk women.